As noted in a previous answer, the birth of Jesus Christ is now estimated by most scholars to have occurred at least a few years earlier. I've seen everything from 7 to 2 BCE -- and yes, in this particular sentence, using the abbreviation BC seems to me an oxymoron. In any case, "common era" solves this problem by just admitting that we're using a common convention, which even Christian scholars now widely regard as inaccurate.
But it's still a convenient and "common" way of referring to our "era" of year reckoning. Insisting that we hold onto the older style too seems to be promoting ignorance of the fact that the abbreviations are literally false. They cause confusion. One item of confusion occurs because of the erroneous after death etymology above. I distinctly recall asking someone about this when I was a small child: "So how do they number the years while Jesus was alive?
But even if we understand what AD means, the convention can create confusion even when Christian scholars are trying to refer to, well, the years around the time of Jesus Christ. Dates in the early Church are a bit uncertain anyhow, but if a Christian scholar is trying to relate a possible date to the timeline of Jesus Christ's life, you have to do a little conversion in your head. In other words, when a reference to the timing of Christ's birth should have maximum usefulness due to proximity of the dates, it actually breeds confusion.
Any one of these reasons alone wouldn't be enough to argue for a new convention. After all, there are all sorts of inconsistent and illogical stylistic elements in English usage. But when you take into account that the old meanings are widely believed even by Christians to be actually wrong, you now have a convention that's actively creating confusion.
BC is "before christ", whether you believe in him or not. It's just as good as the Nth year of reign of Pharaoh Whoever - doesn't require you to believe in the deity of a particular egyptian. Archaeologists also use BP - before present - which is confusingly set as Astronomers of course have the best solution - just count days. Well, successful in that the name changed, but not so successful since the numbers are still exactly the same, and still have an end and start at the traditional year of the birth of Christ.
Today, many cultures continue to use their traditional calendars for marking holidays and cultural events, the day-to-day dates of events is based Gregorian calendar.
In particular, Christian leaders wanted a set and agreed upon date for Easter. Enter the monk Dionysius Exiguus, who lived in what is today Romania and Bulgaria.
Some scholars think he used astrological signs, while others believe he based his assertion on the Bible. What we do know, however, is that Dionysius was successful in promoting his timeline, and it became the standard used to this day. Suddenly, there was a systematic way to label the years that happened after the year that Dionysius declared Jesus was born, and it counted backward rather than forward. Of note: zero never made it into the equation.
Regardless of the confusion on dates and the missing zero, the BC and AD way of labeling time caught on thanks to Charlemagne, who ruled much of Western Europe in the late s. They argue that the entire Gregorian Calendar is Christian in nature anyway, so why should we attempt to obscure that fact?
Others ask why such a well-established and functional system should be replaced, arguing that the existence of two competing abbreviations is likely to cause confusion.
Since there are compelling arguments for each system and both are in regular use, we do not recommend one over the other. Given the choice, writers are free to apply their own preference or that of their audience, although they should use their chosen system consistently, meaning BC and CE should not be used together, or vice versa.
There are also some typographical conventions to consider:. As a result, dates that occurred within the last few centuries are rarely marked with CE or AD. English plurals can be puzzling. The plural of goose is geese , but a snake needs to be on the lookout for mongooses. Thanks for your patience. Drag a word to its definition. You have answered 0 of 3 questions correctly and your score is:.
Want to add a little wonder to your website? Help spread the wonder of families learning together. We sent you SMS, for complete subscription please reply. Follow Twitter Instagram Facebook. What do A. What is the Gregorian calendar? How many different calendars are there? Wonder What's Next? Try It Out Find an adult who can help you with one or more of the activities below!
Share what you learned with a friend or family member. Did they know there were so many calendars in the world? Learn more about ancient calendars. Read about the Maya calendar or Julian calendar. How are these similar or different from the Gregorian calendar? Make a Venn diagram or table to explain. Do you have a calendar at home? If not, make your own! Then, ask a friend or family member to help you fill it in.
What important dates will you mark? Are there any holidays or special events coming up? Keeping a detailed calendar can help you stay organized!
0コメント